Mum’s need help – and shouldn’t feel guilty for needed it.

This blog post by Jennifer Fulwiler , which I read ages ago and am only just getting my act together to blog on, says, with much better grammar, something I’ve been saying for a looooong time.  In the comments thread someone else says something I’ve been saying for just as long – that until very recently mothers with young families had that help and didn’t have to feel guilty. It was pure coincidence that I saw a report from the UK a couple of days later, that said stay at home mothers are more depressed than those who go out to work and the reason – according to this report – was that SAHMs are left all day with little children and no adult company. In other words they have no support of any kind.  I also wondered how many of these depressed stay at home mums had husbands who worked such long hours they were essentially single mums, and how many had no dad in the home at all – but it didn’t say.

The comments on Jennifer Fulwiler’s blog post show some of the problems all of us mums at home face. First of all, far too many mothers have no immediate family support. The days when families lived and grew together are long gone. Most adult children live quite some distance from their parents and so the old-fashioned support of a mother to her daughter when the babies start coming, just isn’t there for many. On top of that is the very real problem that far too many couples beginning family life have come from abusive and chaotic childhoods where even if mum did live round the corner, you wouldn’t want her near you or your children.

The other big problem that is newer, is that many SAHM find she is the only mother at home with her own children. All the other mothers are out at work and the children out at nurseries or child minders. For some of my friends this means that working mums think they are the fall back child care. This can happen even when the family are in crisis – but the neighbour wants her kids picked up from school anyway.

It was picked up on that in the past, before the end of the Second World War at any rate, even fairly poor families could afford a servant to help with housework and child care. In fact I have been reading the story of Ven Anna Maria Taigi and I was surprised to see that even though they were dirt poor, they still had a servant. Even people like us, who are not on the bottom of the financial heap can’t afford regular help these days.

One way I think that overcomes some of the problems, apart from shunting aside the guilt for needing help, is to form communities that will work together. In the UK I don’t think home educators are that good at mutual support over all, but if you can form a little group of mums and children who will share lessons, and help each other out in emergencies, it can take a lot of stress out of life and make the business of being at home with the children less lonely and frustrating.

A cultural shift in attitudes towards mothers who dare to care for their own children might help too, but in the meantime, we mums need to stick together.

Home educators, even in this country, seem to have more children on average than other families. I think as the children grow older and having been at home together, learning together and forming closer family relationships, that as they reach adulthood, they will more naturally look out for one another. I certainly hope so. I want my children to support one another through the rest of their lives, to be the good uncles and aunts to their nephews and nieces, and be close enough to us that we can be proper grandparents (God willing).

If you don’t have family, then you need to make an alternative family. Close friendships in HE can make that work.

There are a couple of items that came up in the comments of Jennifer’s blog that I want to return to. They seem to reflect a certain cultural understanding that seems to me directly opposed to a Christian worldview and I was a bit shocked to see them written ostensibly by Catholics.


7 responses to “Mum’s need help – and shouldn’t feel guilty for needed it.

  1. We deliberately bought a house near both sets of parents so that we could be close to our families when we had children. My mum doesn’t work and only lives two roads away and I see her several times a week. I have felt like I’m cheating, almost, as I have far more support than almost every other mum I know (many not even living in the same country as their families!). I’ve also been made to feel guilty about it, for the amount of help that she gives me. Almost all my mum friends have gone back to work and so rely on childminders or school. Choosing to be a SAHM and choosing to HE, can be very lonely!

    • Clare, you are living the way we are supposed to be, of that I am increasingly convinced.
      There is no shame and should be no guilt, in families working and caring together.

  2. My friends and I call it building a tribe. We all have slightly different members in our tribes but we have them. My tribe extends from British Columbia to the Far East, Australia to Norway! Obviously those further away are moral supporters and advisers and those closer can help out in a more practical way. And yes some help I pay for! But boy does that make one feel guilty……

    • Yes Alison, I think that’s basically what I’ve been doing all my life. I have a “mum” who isn’t my mum but who has been a brilliant mum person and have gradually built a “tribe” as you put it, where even if we have no family who will or can support us, we can support one another, even as you point out, from some considerable distances.

  3. “For some of my friends this means that working mums think they are the fall back child care”.

    This happened to me a few times, one time the parents of a friend of my daughter’s wanted me to pick her up from school on the days when her high school sister couldn’t. When I said that I couldn’t be sure that I would be available every time they were incredulous, almost offended, that I would say no. With the subtext being, ‘you have nothing better to do, why don’t you do something for us more worthy full-time workers’.

    Personally, I live near my Mum and Dad, and we have a very full life in the church. But there certainly have been times when I’ve been lonely, especially when the girls were very little.

    • I must admit this is one of those things that bugs me a little. We are lesser beings for being at home with our children and often even lesser still for home educating them, until the working parent needs someone to be there for their kids.
      The other side of this that I have personally experienced is children who need an adult to talk to, and end up telling me stuff about school or just life that when I tell them to make sure mum and dad know, admit they rarely see them long enough to talk to them.
      There has to be a way to support working parents so at least one of them is available for the children.

  4. Pingback: Handling Issues: The New Definition of Family .:. BlissPlan: Reaching Bliss Through Powerful Information

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s